Future Heroes: Cleveland Indians Minor Leaguers Show Promise

The more I watch the Cleveland Indians' minor league position players (Beau Mills pictured left) compete this spring training, the more I have become impressed. With the WBC adding 2 more weeks to Cactus League actions, plenty of minor leaguers from all levels have appeared in games. Granted, there is only been a weeks' worth of games, but I have a strong feeling of good things to come for many of these guys. Here are just some of the highlights...

Luis Valbuena: Yet to get a hit in 8 at bats, but has looked great at second and short stop around the bag. Saw him hit in the cages and the ball really popped off of his bat.

Trevor Crowe: Switch hitter has batted already 15 times and looks to be a viable candidate for the 4th outfield spot. Needs to show consistency at the plate, but covers a lot of ground in center and in left.

Beau Mills: Hit his first Cactus League home run Wednesday off of Chad Gaudin which was described as a moon shot. .357 batting average in 14 AB's, driven in 4 runs to go with a double and a triple. Mills has had some issues with the flip play with the pitcher covering first. Definitely needs to refine his fielding skills, but his bat looks almost ready.

Michael Brantley: Played a decent outfield, has 3 hits in 12 AB's, seems to be a slap hitter know so he should fill out his lean frame. Hopefully AAA won't be a major adjustment for him as he is only 21 but the coaches seem to feel his work ethic will allow him to progress smoothly.

Here is some footage of Brantley in the cage...



Stephen Head: Cranked a home run in first cactus game against the Giants, looks good at first base and besides his error in right seems to be a future 4th outfielder/utility guy of value.

Matt LaPorta: 4 hits in 11 at bats, hit a home run off of Dan Haren, and seems to be playing ok out in left field. Future Tribe slugger should see action with the big league club sometime this summer.

Wes Hodges: 3 for 11, going to be playing a lot with Mark DeRosa in the WBC. Needs to work on all facets of his defensive game but still seems to be the Tribe's future third baseman.

Jordan Brown: 3 for 9, with a home run and 2 runs batted in. Seems to be the forgotten man this camp as he was left off of the 40 man roster. Jordan has something to prove and I believe can be an everyday first baseman somewhere in the league, just probably not in Cleveland.

Chris Gimenez: Has played all over the field this spring (Catcher, 3rd, Outfield), while 2 of his 3 hits have been doubles. Gimenez will be seen up with the Indians sometime this year as his versatility is outstanding. OBP is .538, a stat he has excelled in at every level.

Carlos Santana: Shown a rifle for an arm, is gaining a lot of valuable experience working with the big league club. Santana has looked over matched at times, but has drawn 3 walks in 11 plate appearance which shows he is staying patient and not trying to over impress.

Nick Weglarz: 21 year old Canadian is 0 for 4 but gained some important time watching the studs of the big league club. It will be interesting to see how many at bats he gets in the WBC for Team Canada.

Here is some game footage of Weglarz in action...



Carlos Rivero: Soon-to-be 21 year old went 2-3 with a double and an RBI in his first game playing in a Major League game with the Indians. Top 10 Tribe Prospect will start the year in Akron and may be a name to watch.

It will be interesting to see how many of these guys contribute to the big league club in the future. I would imagine someone between Hodges, Mills, LaPorta, and Weglarz will be moved for pitching as they are all similar type players (as is Head,Brown, and Michael Aubrey). The Indians have really went away from overloading camp with the hangers on (Graffanino, Merchan, and Valdez type) and given their young guys shots at major league pitching. These prospects will be donning the blue and red in the next few years so get used to their names now so you have the pleasure of saying, "I remember that guy from Spring Training!"

Sizemore Conspiracy? Something to Choo on.

Tribe centerfielder Grady Sizeomore was a late scratch from Team USA competing in the World Baseball Classic. A mysterious groin injury occurred last Thursday, and Sizemore and the Indians came to the conclusion that he needed to be shut down for a week and evaluate his health. Now Grady is expected to be back in the lineup Friday to DH. Now I imagine initially Sizemore was pumped to play for his country in this made up exhibition amongst countries. It does seem odd to me that after going 2-3, stealing a base, and then going out to his position in center, he somehow aggravated this nagging groin problem.
I was able to capture video of both hits and his stolen base so make the call with your own eyes.










Guy looked fine to me! Sizemore staying in Goodyear is definitely a good thing for the Indians, so don't confuse these clips with the JFK tapes. With the news of Shin Soo Choo have arm issues out in Korea somewhere, all Tribe fans should be greatful so few of their own players are competing (DeRosa, Perez, Weglarz, Espino are about it for now). This contrived World Cupesque baseball charade needs to either be played in October or not be held at all. The starting pitchers will only really be able to throw 3-5 innings at a maximum, and they will not be at their peak of performance at all. It takes these guys usually all of spring training to get up to the 80-100 pitch level and that long to be at a top velocity as well. I can only imagine the agony tribe fans would be in watching Cliff Lee throw for Team USA or Fausto Carmona pitch for the Dominican Rebublic. A collective sigh would be heard all the way from Ohio every time they left the mound without injury. Hopefully DeRosa will play often enough to stay fresh and not be glued to the bench as a utility guy. Also, say a little prayer that Rafael Perez is conversely not overused as a setup guy for the Dominican team (he pitched 2 innings in an exhibition game already yesterday). The WBC is a joke and another fleeting attempt by Bud Selig to over expose an event (see All-Star game home field advantage fiasco) as a way to prop up baseball for all the wrong reasons.

Cactus Action

With the Tribe already completing their 7th spring training game and STO not showing a match up until the end of March, I decide to put up some of the game action from last weeks' Diamonbacks game. Nothing real earth-shattering, just some semi regulars getting some work. I think Tomo Ohka is still icing his neck after his forgettable outing

Asdrubal Cabrera grounding out.




Josh Barfield drawing a walk.




Mark Reynolds and Tony Clark batting against Rich Rundles with a cameo from Mark Shapiro.




Dan Haren vs Kelly Shoppach




Mark DeRosa strikes out against Haren




Mark DeRosa Pops up




Grady Sizemore bloops a single




It is always a welcomed site to watch Indians baseball games even if they don't count. Hopefully next year STO will carry games more frequently than over just a two week span.

Are we talking about Practice?

Spring Training is a time where everyone's team has a shot to win a division. Having scene with my own eyes the Indians running the bases and firing baseballs aroung the diamond, I can assure you of one thing. The Indians practices definitely sound just as exciting in the paper as they are in real life. Station to station drills were what was on tap before last Thursday's Diamondback game, as players were in groups of 4 while taking batting practice and leadoff third base practice. The most interesting group was Sizemore/DeRosa/Hafner/Valbuena for sure. The other two groups I witnessed were Hodges/Brantley/Cannizaro/Cabrera and Mills/Head/LaPorta/Espino. I have no idea how or why they were paired in that way, but watching DeRosa interact with Grady and Pronk showed me that he will fit perfectly in with the clubhouse as they were constantly joking around with each other.

The Tribe's brand spanking new training complex in Goodyear, Arizona is about a 10 minute walk from the ballpark, and is literally in the middle of nowhere, next to a literal airplane graveyard. Fans are allowed to watch practice down the right field and left lines of the field closest to the road through a 15 foot high fence. I was able to capture some shots of batting, infield, and outfield practice by standing on top of the bleachers and sticking my camcorder through the openings of the fence. It isn't much, but the following clips are of our favorite baseball players preparing for a hopefully exciting season.

Clip 1 Eric Wedge Rallying the troops...


Clip 2 A little outfield work...


Clip 3 Guys jogging on the field... (shocking video)


Clip 4 Guys walking off of the field... (mesmerizing stuff!)


Clip 5 Grady stretching and guys leading off third base..


Clip 6 Some more Indians leading off of Third...


Clip 7 Running the bases with the Tribe!


Clip 8 The Indians taking some grounders...


I hope this provides a little more insight into what the Indians do on a daily basis and what the new practice field looks like. Manager Eric Wedge definitely has them on a strict routine and is loving the flexibility the new complex is affording his players and staff. Arizona is definitely a desert, but definitely more like home watching Indians uniforms run around. Tuesday's TTO will feature clips from the game against the Diamondbacks.

Down on the Farm Report (Spring Training Addition): Matt Laporta

Last Thursday, Matt LaPorta hit his first Spring Training home run against Arizona Diamondbacks starter Dan Haren. Is this a sign of a future Manny Ramirez or Russell Branyan? That is what February and March baseball provides the fan, hope or skepticism. Now we all know Spring Training games don't count for much, but it does allow the avid fan to see the minor league guys compete in semi-meaningful games against some major leaguers.

Fielding Left Field is much different in the show, as LaPorta learned that same day. The error he was charged with had to big issues, he misplayed the ball and did not communicate real well with Grady Sizemore. These problems often lead to better things to come for a minor leaguer as it presents an area of improvement on a semi-big stage.

Although his glove is not ready for prime time yet, LaPorta is by the day showing the Tribe why they chose him as the number one prospect in the CC Sabathia deal.

LaPorta shows all of the promise of a big league slugger. He is listed at 6-2, 210 lbs, but seems even bigger in person. With the lack of a true power hitting right handed batter on the big league club, the former Gator looks poised to make the jump to the Majors sometime in 2009. But the reality is he probably would be at best a September call-up due to him only being in the professional baseball for 2 full seasons.

The more I see of the position player prospects in the Indians oraganization, the more I get excited for the teams' short term and long term success. Now let's just hope the Tribe has some pitchers on the farm that impress as much as Matt LaPorta does. The dinger he hit was a bomb off of an All-Star, an occurrence that the Indians hope to see for many years to come.

More to come tomorrow as Tribe Times will show videos from Indians Practice, game action, and more!

Spring Training Review Coming Soon!

Tribe Times is back from the valley of the sun and will be sharing plenty of content over the next week. I was able to attend last Thursday and Friday's games, along with one practice. Because YouTube is so slow, video will be shown as soon as it can be put on the site. Look forward to see action from..

Grady Sizemore, Travis Hafner, Mark DeRosa, Kelly Shoppach, Matt Laporta, Nick Weglarz, Michael Brantley, Beau Mills, Stephen Head, Asdrubal Cabrera, and more.

Sal Fasano Flashback

In anticipation of 2009, I wanted to share a few quick photos from the late September game against Detroit where Fausto Carmona beat the crap out of Gary Sheffield. I am happy we are turning the page on a tough season, but watching the replay of this game gave me some more hope for this season. Choo looked amazing in hitting two home runs, Grady was Grady belting a bomb into center, Fausto pitched OK until being ejected, and Betancourt threw like his old self. And Sal Fasano looked like a beer league softball player. I won't miss the injuries and inconsistancies, but I sure will miss the italian stallion, as I will forever be one of Sal's Pals.



Sal in a comfy sweatshirt

Sal cooling off Fausto

and finally Fausto winding up and delivering a fist sandwich to Gary Sheffield. What a game and what an incident! The Colorado Rockies have one great Spring Training Invitee!

Marte Gone, Tribe trades for Reliever

With all of the trade talk involving another Cleveland team today, it was the Indians who pulled the trigger on a deal. The Indians obtained 30 year old right handed reliever Juan Salas from the Tampa Bay Rays. Salas is pretty much a career minor leaguer, so the Indians must see something in this guy to add him to 40 man roster. The move means the end to third baseman of the future Andy Marte. Marte compiled a career batting average of .211 with 9 HRs and 52 RBI in 513 at bats. Hopefully Andy will be claimed by another franchise because I can't imagine the Tribe even sending him to Triple A at this point with Wes Hodges slotted for Columbus.

Meet the Tribe: The Position Players

Tribe #1 Prospect Carlos Santana (pictured right) seems ready for another Tribe preview, so here goes..

And now, the much anticipated Part 2 Position Player version of Meet the Tribe! Most of the information here has been recited at nauseum all over the newspapers and internet, but what can one more guys opinion hurt?

Catchers
79 Chris Gimenez: Chris was added to the 40 man roster in December before the Rule 5 draft. He is a jack of all trades type player, possessing the ability to play Catcher, First, Third, and both corner outfield positions. Gimenez was moved to Catcher in 2006, but probably won't see much time there in the majors as an Indian with Martinez and Shoppach blocking that path, along with super prospect Carlos Santana behind him in Double A. He is an excellent on base guy and will likely gain more power the more experience he gains. Best case scenario for this 26 year old would be a role as a super utility guy for the Tribe in 2010, or possibly if injuries occur in 2009.

Interesting Tidbit...Won Single A Carolina Homerun Derby in 2007.

41 Victor Martinez: Groin and Elbow problems sidelined Victor for most of 2008 as he only appeared in 73 games. The elbow seemed to be the toughest injury to overcome as he only hit 2 homeruns in 266 at bats and slugged a pedestrian .365, way below his season averages. This a big year for V-Mart as his is just 2 years away from free agency and needs to re demonstrates his durability. Manager Eric Wedge has stated that he will catch all of Fausto Carmona's starts and have an increased workload at first base. Expect to see the Victor of old as he returns to the elite AL hitter he always has been.

Interesting Tidbit: His favorite movie is Catch Me if You Can.

77 Carlos Santana: Traded from Dodgers with Jon Meloan in Casey Blake deal. Soon to 23 year old has torn up the minors, batting .330 between two Single A clubs in 2008 while belting 20 homeruns and driving in 115 RBI's resulting in an MVP award. Santana is a switch hitter and apparently has that natural sweet sound radiating off his bat when he makes contact. An athletic guy who continues to grow, this Dominican has a strong arm and is assimilating to the catching position quite well in only his 2nd year behind the dish (converted 3rd Baseman/Outfielder). Look for Carlos to be the Indians starting Catcher in 2011, if not as early as the second half of 2010.

Interesting Tidbit: Number 1 rated prospect in Indians organization (5 star) by Baseball America.

10 Kelly Shoppach: Shoppach had a breakout 2008 season, leading all American League catchers with 21 homeruns in only 352 at bats. Along with being Cliff Lee's personal catcher, Kelly will see more time behind the dish with Victor seeing an increased workload at First Base. Needs to cut down on the K's as over 1/3 of his at bats resulted in strikeouts (133). Another season like 2008 and Shoppach will not have to worry about splitting time again.

Interesting Tidbit: His favorite athlete growing up was Bo Jackson.

76 Wyatt Toregas: This 26 year old has the defensive tools to be a major league catcher right now, but needs to find consistency with his bat. Batted .219 in Triple A before being demoted and refocused his game. Played great in Akron, hitting .296 with 12 homeruns. Probably projects to be a backup in the majors, but will probably be the first call up if Martinez or Shoppach get hurt, which is a better option than 2008 clunkers Yamid Haad and Sal Fasano.

Interesting Tidbit: Wrestled and played golf in high school.

Non Roster Invite
65 Damaso Espino: Espino is primarily in camp to help catch all of the pitchers on the roster and add possible minor league depth. Batted .275 in Double A Akron and also played in 13 games for Triple A Omaha (Royals).

Interesting Tidbit: May play for Panama in 2009 World Baseball Classic.

Infielders
29 Josh Barfield: Spring Training will be a big transition period for Josh, as he will be asked to expand his game into playing more positions (SS, 3B, Outfield). He has the athleticism and speed to succeed as a 25th man, as I am sure the alternative (Columbus) would not be acceptable. Barfield needs to show some glimpses of his 2006 year with the Padres to ever be considered an everyday player again. Still only 26, should embrace the challenge of making the team and not sulk about the predicament. Should break camp with the Big League club.

Interesting Tidbit: Father Jesse played 12 seasons in the majors, hitting 241 career homeruns.

13 Asdrubal Cabrera: It was a tale of two seasons of A-Cab. Before the All-Star break, he looked chubby and unmotivated, batting .184 with 1 HR and 14 RBI in 158 at bats. He was subsequently sent down to get in shape and see how he would react to the demotion. Cabrera rebounded quite nicely, batting a cool .320 with 5 homeruns and 33 RBI in 194 AB's. Still only 23 years old, should bounce back to an average AL secondbaseman with above average defensive ability.

Interesting Tidbit: Turned an unassisted triple play against the Toronto Blue Jays in 2008, only the 14th in baseball history.

11 Jamey Carroll: Carroll fit in quite nicely with his new team last year, hitting .277 in 113 games. Carroll demostrated his versitility as he split time between 3B and 2b filling the role as the Tribe's main utility man. He should see some time in the corner outfield positions in 2009 as well. Made only 9 errors all year.

Interesting Tidbit: Member of University of Evansville (Ind) Hall of Fame (former teammate Sal Fasano is in there too, a must visit for any Tribe or mustache fan.)

7 Mark DeRosa: Acquired on New Year's eve from the Chicago Cubs for 3 minor league pitchers. DeRosa had a career year in 2008, hitting .285 while belting 21 HR's and 87 RBI. Will bat second in the lineup and will be relied upon to add another spark to the top of the lineup. Played all 4 infield positions and both corner outfield spots last season, but will primarily be used at 3rd Base in 2009. His is known to be a great teammate and leader, the 34 year old is in the last season of his existing contract.

Interesting Tidbit: Married to model Heidi Miller.

25 Ryan Garko: Garko struggled mightily in 2008, but his final 2008 numbers don't paint an accurate picture. He hit a lowly .241 in 85 games before the All-Star game, but rebounded afterwards, hitting .319 in 57 games after. His last 1o games pretty much saved his season, as he a mind boggling .514 with 3 homeruns and 15 RBI's over his final 10 games of the 2008 season. Garko raised his batting average 20 points over the last 12 games, a simply amazing feat. Manager Eric Wedge stated in January that Garko may even take a few balls out in the outfield this spring to see if he could play there in a pinch (gulp). Look for Ryan to get 400-500 at bats between playing first base and DH. As his power number rise (only 14 HR's in 2008) his playing time will rise as well.

Interesting Tidbit: Enjoys chugging Budweisers.

15 Andy Marte: The main prospect acquired in the Coco Crisp trade of 2006, Marte has been a complete flop. With the chance to play third everyday after Casey Blake was traded, he batted .244 after the break in 156 at bats. Still only 25, his baseball career will probably continue elsewhere as he can only play one position (3rd) and doesn't do that very well. If he has a good spring, look for the Indians to try and trade him as he is out of options and probably won't go to Triple A if he clears waivers as they have a good looking prospect (Hodges) expected to start there. The Andy Marte Experiment seems to be over.

Interesting Tidbit: Favorite TV show is Deal or No Deal.

2 Jhonny Peralta: Jhonny had a great 2008, batting .276 with 23 HR's and 89 RBI in 154 games at the age of 26. He is emerging as one of the best hitting shortstops in the league, and hit especially well in the cleanup slot. Played primarily third base in winter ball and will eventually slide over to the position in 2010. Team constantly says he is superb at making the routine play, but his lack of range has been a concern ever since he replaced Omar Vizquel in 2005.

Interesting Tidbit: Reason his name is spelled "Jhonny" because father misspelled "Johnny" on his birth certificate.

1 Luis Valbuena: Luis was part of the 3-team trade that brought him from Seattle (along with Joe Smith from Mets) for Franklin Gutierrez. Valbuena batted over .300 and hit 11 HR's in 452 at bats between Double A and Triple A. This 23 year old projects to be an above average defender and a possible candidate for 2nd Base for the big club in 2010. He is a left handed hitter and played in 18 games for the Mariners in 2008.

Interesting Tidbit: Teammate in Venezuelan winter ball was Asdrubal Cabrera.

Non Roster Invites
68 Michael Aubrey: Former First Round pick got his first taste of the big leagues in 2008, hitting .200 in 45 at bats with 2 homeruns. Was taken off 40 man roster and seems to be primarily a in between Majors/AAA player. Health was always a concern and seems to have eroded his prospect potential. Will start the year in Columbus and probably hope to become a minor league free agent in 2010.

Interesting Tidbit: Favorite TV Show is Grey's Anatomy.

67 Jordan Brown: Brown won back to back minor league MVP's in 2006 and 2007 (high A and AA). Only hit 7 HR's in 2008, so his prospect status has taken a hit. Was taken off 40 man roster and not selected in the Rule 5 draft so look for Jordan to have a bounce back season. If he can ever develop power would become a candidate to play for the Indians in the latter portion of 2009. Look for Brown to be Columbus' opening day first baseman.

Interesting Tidbit: Still only 25 years old.

4 Tony Graffanino: Signed on February 15th to help fill in when WBC participants leave. Had 89 at bats for Triple A Buffalo (Indians) last year and batted .315. Plays all over the infield and corner positions. Long shot to make major league club. Has a career .267 batting average with 6 teams over his 15 year major league career.

Interesting Tidbit: Likes New York style Pizza.

26 Andy Cannizaro: Looking to be utility guy for Triple A Columbus. Batted .321 in 84 at bats for Triple A Buffalo (Indians). Familiar with Columbus, as he played there in parts of the 2005 and 2006 seasons. 30 year old looking to keep his minor league career afloat.

Interesting Tidbit: Was an All American in 2001 with Tulane.

66 Stephen Head: 25 year old is an excellent fielder at first and outfield, projecting to be a bench guy in Triple A. Hit .290 with 13 homeruns in Akron, so his power is not quite where the Indians would like it to be. Similar to Jordan Brown as he is a college guy kind of stuck in no mans' land not being on the 40 man roster. There seems to be a real log jam between him, Aubrey and Brown.

Interesting Tidbit: Attended the University of Mississippi.

68 Wes Hodges: Wes had an outstanding 2008 in Akron as he batted .290 with 18 HR's and 97 RBI. Top 10 prospect projects to be in contention for 3rd Base position in 2010. Needs to work on his defense as he is a big guy that lacks some range. Drafted in the 2nd round in 2007 out of Georgia Tech, he looks to be in the starting lineup in Triple A in 2009, meaning 3 minor league levels in 3 years in the Indians organization.

Interesting Tidbit: Played in the 2008 Futures game at Yankee stadium during the All-Star weekend in 2008.

73 Jesus Merchan: 27 year old was brought in to compete for the shortstop job at Triple A Columbus. Batted an impressive .339 with 4 HR's and 72 RBI in Triple A Tuscon (Diamondbacks) in 2008.

Interesting Tidbit: Named after God's only Son.

78 Beau Mills : 22 year old slugged 21 HR's and drove in 90 RBI while posting a .293 in Single A Kinston in 2008 earning him the MVP of the league. An average defender, Mills possesses the right determination the Tribe is looking for in their players, resulting in his Spring Training Invite. Slotted to start the season at first for Double A Akron, Mills is a top 10 prospect and the Indians first baseman of the future. Beau was the 13th overall selection in the first round of the 2007 draft.

Interesting Tidbit: Father Brad played in the majors with the Montreal Expos and is currently the bench coach for the Boston Red Sox.

8 Wilson Valdez: Has appeared in 111 games in the majors for Dodgers, Mariners, and Padres, compiling a career .211 batting average. Will battle Jesus and Cannizaro for a spot in Columbus. Valdez split the 2008 season playing in Korea and Japan. With the Kia Tigers (Korea) he batted .218 with 13 stolen bases in 47 games while batting .256 and 4 stolen bases in 29 games for the Tokyo Yakult Swallows (Japan).

Interesting Tidbit: Nickname is "el gatito" meaning kitten.

Outfielders
17 Shin-Soo Choo: The Tribe's starting Right Fielder for 2009, Choo batted .309 with 14 HR's and 66 RBI in 94 games in the big leagues last season. Most of the damage was done after the All-Star break as he slammed 11 of the homeruns in just 210 at bats while batting .343. Choo is an average outfielder and regaining his arm strength, finally being totally healed from Tommy John surgery. Seems to be a much better hitter against righties, but still hit .286 against Left-handed pitching. Choo will be a big key to the success of the 2009 Indians and will be counted on to drive runs toward the bottom end of the order.

Interesting Tidbit: Traded to the Indians for guitar weilding first baseman Ben Broussard.
62 Trevor Crowe : Crowe is a former first round pick who has experienced inconsistancy and injuries in his four years in the organization. An average defender, Crowe seems to be more of a 4th outfielder rather than an everyday guy, but he did bat .302 with 9 HR's between Akron and Buffalo last season. This 25 year old switch hitter will probably be the first call-up if any of the outfielders are injured as he is on the 40 man roster. Will start in Centerfield for Triple A Columbus in 2009.

Interesting Tidbit: Father David played on the PGA Tour.

20 David Dellucci: In the final year of his 3 year deal that is paying him over $3.5 million to sit on the bench. 35 year old hit .238 with 11 HR's and 47 RBI in 113 games for the Tribe. Not a great fielder with a weak arm, Dellucci will be a left handed hitter off the bench to spell Francisco and Choo from time to time. If he struggles, don't be surprised for the Indians to cut bait and eat his way to large of a contract.

Interesting Tidbit: Won a World Series Ring as a member of the Arizona Diamondbacks.

12 Ben Francisco: Ben was forced into batting all over the lineup in 2008. He hit 15 HR's and drove in 54 RBI while batting .266 in Left and Right field. Really struggled after the All-Start break, hitting only .236 in his last 57 games. An average defender, the 2009 season will be an important one for Francisco to determine if he is an every day ball player or just a guy with some pop off the bench.

Interesting Tidbit: High School Teammates with Tribe Firstbaseman Ryan Garko.

24 Grady Sizemore: Grady had another superb season in 2008, batting .268 with 33 HR's and 90 RBI while stealing 38 bases from the leadoff spot. Was again named the AL All-Star game and collected his second gold glove. Only batted .247 over his final 53 games, but still posted a .343 on base percentage. Sizemore also struggled against lefties, batting just .224. Sizemore will eventually be moved down to the 3 hole when a better leadoff hitting alternative is presented. Still only 26 years old, Grady has become one of the top 10 players in all of baseball. Thankfully is signed through the 2012 season.

Interesting Tidbit: Was recruited out of high school by the University of Washington to play Quarterback.

Non Roster Invites
61 Michael Brantley: Brantley was the player to be named in the CC Sabathia trade from the Brewers that also netted the Indians Matt Laporta, Rob Bryson, and Zach Jackson. Brantley has an uncanny ability to get on base, posting a .319 batting average and a .395 on base percentage in Double A Huntsville (Brewers) as a 21 year old. Struck out only 27 times in 420 at bats last season, demonstrating amazing plate discipline. Plays a decent outfield and figures to play all three positions in Columbus in 2009. Has all the tools to be a future leadoff hitter.

Interesting Tidbit: Father Mickey Brantley played in the major leagues for the Seattle Mariners.

71 Matt LaPorta: The centerpiece of the CC Sabathia trade, Laporta projects to be a major power hitter for years to come. He was a first round pick by the Brewers in 2007, he hit 20 HR's and drove in 66 RBI while batting .288 in just 302 at bats in Double A Huntsville (Brewers). Will focus primarily on Left Field in Columbus, but will be an option in Right and First Base as well. LaPorta was a member of Team USA in the 2008 Olympics and also appeared in the Futures game during All Star weekend. Has developed great pitch recognition, allowing his patience at the plate to result in good hitters' counts and walks. Is often compared to Pat Burrell.

Interesting Tidbit: Led the NCAA in Home Runs as a sophomore at the University of Florida.

Designated Hitters
48 Travis Hafner: Travis had a 2008 to forget. Lingering shoulder pain limited Pronk to just 198 at bats. He didn't fare well at all, hitting .197 with 5 HR's and 24 RBI. Surgery was not performed on his shoulder until the offseason, so it is no guarantee that he will be 100% healthy come February 25th. After an average looking 2007 for Hafner's standards. he will be looking to rebound and get back to the elite slugger ole #48 was. Expect Travis to sit against tough lefties, have a day or two off a week, and hopefully slug 30-35 home runs again in 2009.

Interesting Tidbit: Lives in Cleveland year round.

Look for one more post this week and then Tribe Times is off to Goodyear, Arizona! I will be attending the February 26th game agains the Arizona Diamondbacks so look for a bunch of info the following week with video and pictures. Golfing in February will be a nice perk as well.

Meet the Tribe... Pitching Edition

Every year I watch spring training and end up seeing numbers in the 60's and 70's donning the uniforms of my favorite ball club, the Cleveland Indians and have no clue who they are. This year I have put an end to that as the following article has the names and numbers (with a brief commentary) of all 59 players invited to Goodyear, Arizona this Cactus season. Some will be huge contributors, others will be inevidably cut by the second week of March. Just print a copy off, tune into STO on February 25th, and start dreaming of another odd year playoff appearance. Today will focus on the Pitchers, and Sunday will focus on the position players.

Pitchers

63 Rafael Betancourt Raffy right's 2009 season is a big one for both the Tribe and him. Will he repeat his disappointing 2008 or rekindle the his magical 2007 campaign? Bet on somewhere in the middle to be true. Imagine Indians brass is betting on him not pitching in the WBC (Venezuela) and focusing on spotting his fastball. 2010 is a club option so Raffy will need to prove to the Indians he is back. Hopefully 2008 was more of an abberation than an impending decline.
Interesting Tid Bit... Victor Martinez is the Godfather to his Betancourt's son.
55 Fausto Carmona Can Fausto cut down his walks and baffle A.L. hitters with his wicked slider? The Indians are leaning heavily on Carmona to help stabilize the 2 slot in the rotation. If his walks are down, his consistancy will return. Showed toughness and grit while pounding Gary Sheffield's face in late September game against Detroit. Just turned 25 in December.
Interesting Tid Bit... Fausto favorite movie? Major League 2.
57 Zach Jackson Zach has an outside shot at the roster as either a 5th starter or 7th man out of the pen. More likely headed to the Columbus rotation. One of four players acquired from Milwaukee in CC trade.
Interesting Tid Bit... Jackson's last two starts of 2008 were impressive, earning wins against eventual A.L. playoff participants Boston and Chicago (13 innings, 4 earned runs, 8 K's).
30 Masahide Kobayashi Kobayashi has a lot to prove in 2009 after pitching inconsistant the second half of last season. Club feels that Kobayashi wore down and only allowed him to throw in 3 games in September, eventually shutting him down after September 13th.
Intersting Tid Bit... Cousin to world renown Hot Dog eating champion Kobayashi. (no, not really).
32 Aaron Laffey Was A.L. Rookie Pitcher of the Month for May, developed some elbow trouble, and was eventually shut down for the season. Leading candidate to be teams' 5th starter. Lived in Cleveland during off season to refocus and train for 2009. Tribe brass still high on him as he lefty is just turning 24 in April and despite struggles posted a 4.23 ERA in 16 starts.
Interesting Tid Bit... Loves listening to 2Pac.
31 Cliff Lee What can you say about ole Clifton? 2008 Cy Young winner, All-Star starter, 22 game winner. If he is anywhere close to the pitcher he was last year, losing CC will be much easier to deal with. Mind Boggling 2.54 ERA with 170 K's. Ace of the staff.
Interesting Tid Bit...Lee's middle name is Phifer.
50 Jensen Lewis Was 13-13 in save opportunities as Tribe's de facto closer. Stuggled with velocity early on in 2008, but rebounded quite well posting a 1.59 era over his last 10 outings. Lewis will be relied upon as a 7th and 8th inning guy with having the potential to fill in at closer if Kerry Wood needs a day off or is placed on the Disabled List.
Interesting Tid Bit... Was college teammate to fellow Tribe pitcher Jeremy Sowers.
46 Scott Lewis This Ohio State Alum has an outside shot at the 5th slot in the rotation, more likely headed back home to Columbus. Won all 4 starts he made for the Indians in September, posting a 2.63 ERA. Threw a shutout in his Major League Debut.
Interesting Tid Bit... Majored in Sociology at THE Ohio State University.
59 John Meloan Right hander acquired from the Dodgers in the Casey Blake trade. Pegged as a late inning option in Triple A. Throws fastball in mid 90's, will be one of the first call ups if bullpen struggles.
Interesting Tid Bit... K'd 2 in his 2 games pitched last season in the majors with the Indians.
72 Adam Miller The eternal prospect who only just turned 24 in November. Fastball in upper 90's, but can't stay healthy. Reportedly 100% (we'll see) as his finger problems are apparently behind him. Has been moved to the bullpen to try and keep him on the field for an extended time. Outside shot at making the team as the 7th option out of the pen. May still be a starter again someday.
Interesting Tid Bit... Enjoys meat sandwiches.
49 Edward Mujica Posted a 6.75 ERA over 33 games, but actually went through a 10 inning scoreless streak, which means when he is bad, he is God awful. Out of options so has a shot at making the bullpen. More likely sent packing after lighting the Arizona sky with Rawlings products.
Interesting Tid Bit... Resides in Yagua, Venezuela. Hope he stays there come February 12th.
44 Carl Pavano Was blasted mercilessly and basically compared to a part of the female anatomy in Joe Torre's book. Dated Alyssa Milano. Pitched really crappy over his four years in New York. Indians hoping he can regain his 2004 form (big stretch) and be the teams' 3rd starter.
Interesting Tid Bit... May be arrested in June 2009 for stealing $1.5 million from Cleveland and its fans.
53 Rafael Perez Pitched solid in 2008, will probably be the only Lefty out of the pen. Likely main set up guy looking to continue his consistantcy. Posted a 3.54 ERA over 76 plus innings. An unsung contributor.
Interesting Tid Bit... Turns 27 in May.
27 Anthony Reyes Out of options, has inside track at 4th slot in the rotation. Put together 5 solid starts (2-1, 1.83 ERA in 34 plus innings) for the Tribe before being shut down September 5th as a precausion. Former top prospect for St. Louis needs to stay healthy to ever be counted on.
Interesting Tid Bit... Lost 10 straight games to start 2007 season.
75 Hector Rondon Soon to be 21 year old ticketed as ace of the Akron staff. Went 11-6 at Single A Kinston and rated as a top 10 prospect by Baseball America. Fastball clocked in the mid 90's.
Interesting Tid Bit... Played in the 2007 Futures game for the World Team during All-Star weekend.
56 Rich Rundles 6'5 Lefty gave up only one run over 5 innings of work over 8 games last September for the Tribe. Primarily a matchup lefty who is a great bullpen depth option who will probably start the season in Columbus. Will definitely see time in the Big Leagues in 2009.
Interesting Tid Bit... Throws side-arm.
70 Tony Sipp The off injured Sipp looks to rebound from Tommy John surgery. Looking to round out an impressive Columbus bullpen. Left hander experienced more arm pain in Winter Ball so the team is being cautiously optimistic in his return.
Interesting Tid Bit... Sports a career 2.74 ERA in the minors.
38 Joe Smith Acquired in December from the Mets as part of the 3 team deal involving Franklin Gutierrez. Sidearmer posted a 2.57 era over his last 10 games while New York was in the playoff hunt. Righties batted .192 against him. Virtual lock to make club as a matchup guy out of the pen.
Interesting Tid Bit... Grandparents live in Bay Village, Ohio.
45 Jeremy Sowers Jeremy's 2008 campaign was a roller coaster of a season that went primarily down, posting 4 wins in 22 starts with an ERA above 5. In the mix for the 5th slot, but pretty much a depth option. Former #1 pick has been unable to his 2006 form when he won 7 games and posted a 3.57 ERA. His velocity is up, but the difference between his fastball and changeup is to low (5mph) to be consistantly effective against major league hitters.
Interesting Tid Bit... Favorite music is New Wave and 80's. or loves the band AH-HA.
37 Jake Westbrook Jake signed a 3-year 30 million dollar contract in 2007 and subsequently needed Tommy John surgery causing Tribe fans to utter the phrase "only in Cleveland." Will try to make it back after the All-Star break to contrinbute to a hopeful playoff run. Westbrook is a hard worker and will be back to his regular form by 2010.
Interesting Tid Bit... Was traded to the Indians back in 2000 from the Yankees as part of the David Justice deal along with Zach Day and Ricky Ledee.
34 Kerry Wood Signed a 2 year, $20.5 million dollar deal with a $11 million vesting option in 2011. Saved 34 of 40 games for division winning Cubs. Tribe hopeful long history of arm troubles stay away. First fire baller to close for the Indians since John Rocker.
Interesting Tid Bit... Struck out 20 batters in one game in 1998.

Non Roster Invites
36 Greg Aquino posted a 2.45 ERA in 23 innings for Triple A Norfolk in 2008. Had 12.54 ERA in 9 games as an Oriole. Started season on 25-man roster.
Interesting Tid Bit... Was originally an infielder.
58 Jack Cassel 28 year righty pitched in 9 games for the Astros, posting a 5.64 ERA. Triple A bullpen option.
Interesting Tid Bit... Brother is New England Patriots QB Matt Cassel. Seriously!
39 Vinnie Chulk In the mix (longshot) for last bullpen spot. Posted a 4.83 ERA in 27 games for the Giants. Never was recalled after being sent to the minors in June, pitched adequately in Triple A Fresno, with a 3.65 ERA over 24 plus innings. Major contributor to SF bullpen in 2007 where he pitched in 57 games, going 5-4 with a 3.57 ERA.
Interesting Tid Bit... Has a degree in sports management.
64 Ryan Edell Lefty posted a 7-8 record with a 3.80 ERA over 26 starts in Double A Akron in 2008. Has excellent arm control meaning he slots the arm angle on his pitches mostly the same. Not much of a power pitcher as he throws in the low 90's. Likely an eventual bullpen candidate as a long man in Columbus.
Interesting Tid Bit... Likes eating Hamburgers.
40 Matt Herges 38 year old pitched in 58 games for Colorado in 2008, going 3-4 with a 5.04 ERA. Has appeared in 537 games over his 12 major league career for the Dodgers, Expos, Padres, Giants, Diamondbacks, Marlins and Rockies. First try at the A.L. Long shot to make bullpen, but may give Triple A a try. Threw 3 shutout innings in 2007 World Series.
Interesting Tid Bit... Was named in the Mitchell Report for taking Performance Inhancing Drugs.
69 David Huff 2008 Indians Minor League Pitcher of the Year. Lefty was 1st round pick out of UCLA in 2006. Real shot at rotation out of Spring Training, will definitely be first call up if doesn't break camp with the big league club. Demonstrates outstanding control as he only walked 29 batters in 26 minor league starts in 2008. Compiled a 5-1 record with a 1.92 ERA in Akron over 11 games. Went 6-4 with a 3.01 ERA in Buffalo over 16 starts. A Strike Trower who has a solid velocity (94mph fastball).
Interesting Tid Bit... Favorite player growing up was Tom Glavine.
16 Tomo Ohka Triple A Starting Pitching Depth Option. Has career 50-62 record in the big leagues. Went 5-11 with a 4.18 ERA in Triple A Charlotte in 2008 (White Sox affiliate).
Interesting Tid Bit... Mentioned in 2003 episode of The Simpsons.
54 Kirk Saarloos Spent most of 2008 season in Triple A Sacramento for Oakland as a starter, posting a 9-4 record and 4.22 ERA in 22 starts. Should make the rotation in Columbus.
Interesting Tid Bit... Career Record is 29-30 with a 5.02 ERA.

Special thanks to Tony Lastoria's book "2009 Cleveland Indians Top 100 Prospects" for his analysis on Tribe minor leaguers. You can purchase his book at his site http://www.indiansprospectinsider.com/. Phenominal Tribe Resource!

3 Burning Tribe Questions

In celebration of the various lists, previews, and breakdowns circulating around the Internet concerning the 2009 MLB season, Tribe Times has decided to jump into the fray. With the equipment trucks on their way to Arizona (yawn), and the most recent news of the Indians signing Vinnie Chulk (bigger yawn), let's get the prognostications flowing...

1. Can "Hot" Carl Pavano become the teams' 3rd starter?

At first I thought this signing had the makings of a Kevin Milwood-type reclamation project. By further examination, it looks as more likely to turn into a Jason Johnson-type disaster. Pavano has been horrible since 2004, basically suffering through injury after injury. He didn't take to well to the New York media, dated this girl, and was called out by his teammate Mike Mussina (who rarely ever says anything) questioning his intestinal fortitude. Here is an excerpt from spring training 2007.

"When one guy is out there playing the game despite whatever is going on and somebody else is not, that's how teammates get bad tastes in their mouths," Mussina said. "As another starting pitcher, who hasn't been 100 percent for all of the last two years, I know what it takes to be able to go out there and pitch, and I know when you can't go out there and pitch. And sometimes it's a fine line, but I think after 15 years I kind of know where the line is."
Pavano says that one injury led to another and that he finally feels well after working out with a new trainer in Arizona during the offseason. Some of his teammates kept pointing out that each time it appeared he was close to being ready to pitch in the major leagues, another injury occurred.
"I'm looking at from a perspective of just the way each thing happened and the timing of it and just piecing all those things together," Mussina said. "You get to form your own evaluation. It didn't look good. From a player's and a teammate's standpoint, it didn't look good. Was everything just coincidence over and over again? I don't know."

Never a good sign that a guy you may slot in as your number 3 man in your rotation has confidence and toughness issues. The front office has stated that of all of the guys considered as low risk/high reward alternatives (Pavano signed a 1 year 1.5 million incentive laden contract), he was in the best shape and possessed the most confidence. The Tribe brass may be kicking themselves at signing Pavano so early as guys like Ben Sheets and Pedro Martinez, among others are still currently free agents and will likely have to take contracts in the 4-7 million dollar range on one year deals. Granted, the payroll is pretty well maxed out, but if they would have waited and scrounged up another couple million, the team and the fans may have a bit more to feel confident about when you look at the starting rotation. If Pavano has any injury in Spring Training lasting more that a week, I would hope the team cuts bait quickly.

Best Case Scenario:

Pavano regains some Marlin magic and wins 15 games with an era under 4, helping to solidify the middle of the rotation.

Worst Case Scenario:

Carl hurts his arm, shoulder, or whatever and lights the Progressive Field mound on fire after every start, resulting in his ultimate release at the end of May.

Prediction:

Carl muddles through most starts until the All-Star break, eventually getting DL'd for a third time and being replaced by Jake Westbrook by August.

2. Will Travis Hafner rePronk his career?

I have been a huge Hafner fan ever since he was dealt from the Rangers for Einar Diaz and Ryan Drese and hope he can return to his former glory, but the 2009 season may be a make or break for number 48. Red Flags surround the DH, as besides the lost season of 2008, pundits have questioned his sharp statistical decline of 2007 in relation to 2006 when he hit 18 less homers in 23 more games. Terry Pluto recently wrote that he felt for Hafner to be somewhat effective this season, he would need to rest at least once or a twice a week. That is a worrisome proposition in that a guy whose sole responsibility to the team is swinging a bat needs a regular break from doing what he does best can't be a good thing.

The lineup can recover from Pronk sitting a few out as they showed at the end of last year (Kelly Shoppach, take your bow), but Travis seems to be his own harshest critic. A repeat of 2008 would sure to render him frustrated and nothing better than a guy off the bench. The bigger problem would be the 49+ million dollars left on his 4 year deal that would severely hinder the front offices' payroll flexibility if Hafner is rendered useless. The team and player seem confident that all problems in the shoulder have been fixed and we should see the Travis of old in 2009, sans his significant weight loss.

Best Case Scenario:

Hafner his fully healed, plays in 140 games, slugs 35 homeruns, has a OBP soaring over .400 and becomes the feared hitter he was back in 2006. Pronkville Rejoices!!!

Worst Case Scenario:

Elbow flares up, can't get into a rhythm, and we are stuck with a .220 50 million dollar DH for 4 more years

Prediction:

Pronk is tough, and his part project part donkey side takes over. Travis belts 25-30 homeruns, spends one or two short stints on the DL, hits around .270, and hears more cheers than boos at the corner of Carnegie and Ontario.

3. Does Mark DeRosa have what it takes to bat second and be a difference maker?

Everything out of Chicago has been extremely positive about the Tribe's new third baseman. I have heard words like "gamer" and phrases like "great clubhouse guy" when describing DeRosa, but will he produce in the AL? He primarily batted in the second half of the Cubs order, generally being protected from being heavily counted on to spark innings (which DeRosa did on his own to his credit). The Indians haven't had a solid number 2 hitter sans two months of Asdrubal Cabrera in 2007, or more notably since Coco Crisp in 2005. DeRosa seems a pretty solid player to plug in to the 2 hole with his .376 OBP. His 106 K's need to be cut down as he will be more heavily counted on to move runners along by putting the ball in play. The conversion over to the American League shouldn't be an issue as he played for Texas in 2006, having some success. In the past 3 years(2 in Chicago, 1 in Texas, 500 AB's in each season), DeRosa has only manned the hot corner a mere 99 times while committing 9 errors. The team has stated that 3rd Base is his best position, which is up for debate. His fielding percentage at third over the sample size above is .960, while his career FP there is .949, which rank him pretty much average and a slight upgrade over Casey Blake.

The real question will be if Asdrubal struggles a la 2008, or Peralta's lack of range gets worse, will the D-Man be back at second? DeRosa's ultra flexibility to be able to play pretty much anywhere (notably the corner outfield positions) seems to be what really attracted the Indians to the former Wrigleyviller, so don't be surprised to see him all around the diamond. His club friendly $5 million dollar one year contract may also provide this 2010 free agent some incentive to put together another productive season.

Best Case Scenario:

DeRosa further strengthens the top of the order, gets on base, helps set the table for the 3-4-5 hitters, flashes an above average gloves, and helps lead the Wigwamers to another division title.

Worst Case Scenario:

Struggles in April and May with his league transition, forgets how to play third, becomes Casey Blake lite or worse, an overpaid utility infielder and we see Wes Hodges sooner than we would like up in Cleveland.

Prediction:

DeRosa delivers, provides leadership and above average production, and helps the Indians battle deep into September for a very winnable AL Central Division crown.

There are obviously a lot more questions then answers floating around the 2009 Indians. More on those in the coming days, including a Central Division preview that spell out the road for baseball possibly (hopefully) being played in Cleveland in October.

Down on the Farm Report: Michael Brantley

Don't be surprised to see the first player paying dividends received in the CC Sabathia trade for the Indians in 2009 isn't USA Baseball Olympian Matt Laporta. With Pitchers and Catchers reporting to spring training in less than three weeks and WTAM replaying the Carmona/Sheffield brawl game today, my anticipation for another Indian summer is growing by the day. It lead me to ponder one name that seemed to keep popping up during the past weeks' Winter Press tour and if we could see that man roaming the area preceding the Toyota Home Run porch at Progressive Field; Tribe farmhand Outfielder Michael Brantley. Here are some thoughts around the web about this intriguing 21 year old prospect...

from CastroTurf...

There is a chance -- albeit a slim one -- that Matt LaPorta, Michael Brantley or Trevor Crowe could win a big-league job out of camp. Again, though, it's slim, given that the Indians prefer to have those guys getting everyday at-bats in Triple-A. But it's become quite clear that David Dellucci is on a short leash this season. It also doesn't appear likely the Indians will carry five outfielders at the outset of the season.

Brantley is as mature a 21-year-old as you'll ever meet.

from the DiaTribe...

... I don’t know about you, but the 21-year-old version of myself was not the most impressive or mature person that you would meet and Brantley’s poise at a young age, not to mention the fact that he doesn’t turn 22 until May and figures to start the season in AAA, speaks to a self-confidence (not a cockiness) that the special players often exhibit.

... His stature and the fact that he’s still a 21-year-old growing into his body give some validity to Brantley’s comments during our interview a few months ago that scouts had told him that a comp for him was Garrett Anderson…which, at the time, I scoffed at. Certainly appearances are just that, but the on-base skills have always been there for Brantley (.399 career minor-league OBP) and he walked twice as much as he struck out last year in AA Huntsville, so it will be interesting to see if his power grows as his body matures and he moves himself further up the ladder.

Obviously, Brantley’s ability to hit for extra-base hits in AAA will go a long way to determining where he projects to be as a hitter, but know that Garrett Anderson had 42 extra-base hits as a 21-year-old in AAA in 1993 before becoming a fixture in the Angels’ lineup for the next 13 years, so if Brantley shows an ability to drive the ball in Columbus (now that he’s completely healthy and not hampered by the ankle injury that robbed him of some power in the 2nd half of 2008), it could portend good things for the PTBNL in the CC deal.

from Indians Prospect Insider...

I had a chance to talk to a lot of the guys I had talked to over the course of the season, and was able to finally for the first time talk to Brantley in person. He is only 21 and will be the first month or two of the Triple-A season this year, and is already 6'2" 200 pounds and strong. Good kid, and extremely mature. He often gets knocked because of a lack of power, but I believe it will start to show some this year with more doubles and triples. He's going to be special.

Brantley is the son of former Seattle Mariner Outfielder Mickey Brantley and possesses the potential skills the Tribe has been lacking since the departure of the first and second tour of duties of one Kenny Lofton; speed and on base ability. Although Manager Eric Wedge will continually harp on the idea of Grady Sizemore's love for the top spot in the order, the organization has to realize how much stronger the big league club's lineup would be offensively with Grady batting third. Let's illustrate this idea as if Brantley was ready to step into left field in 2009, a position he may be patrolling up in Cleveland by mid season.

1. Brantley LF

2. DeRosa 3B

3. Sizemore CF

4. Martinez C

5. Hafmer DH

6. Peralta SS

7. Choo RF

8. Garko 1B

9. Cabrera 2B

Let's say Cliff Lee is pitching, or a tough lefty is on the mound, or Hafner needs a day off. The lineup could look like this...

1. Brantley LF

2. DeRosa 3B

3. Sizemore CF

4. Martinez 1B

5. Peralta SS

6. Garko DH

7. Shoppach C

8. Francisco RF

9. Cabrera 2B

The first lineup features Garko batting 8th, which would immediately rank among the American League's best. And the second group is not too shaby either, taking into account that Pronk is going to need more days off this year than in years past. Sizemore in the 3 hole would increase the explosiveness of the daily 1-9 and allow Grady more opportunities to drive in runs. With David Dellucci apparently on a short leash according to Castrovince, the Indians won't hesitate to shake up the outfield in 2009. Also, Shin Soo Choo destroyed right handed pitching last year and may need a platoon mate, and who better than Ben Francisco to be that guy. Ben has demonstrated his ability to hit at the major league level somewhat, but he probably is more suited to be a 4th outfielder rather than an everyday guy. Obviously these scenarios are contingent on Brantley making an adjustment to Triple A Columbus, but his track record seems to point towards a smooth transition. Here is some more analysis from Tony Lastoria over at Indians Prospects Insider...

At only 21 years of age, Brantley has raced up the prospect rankings and climbed the minor league ladder quickly to where he just finished his second season - his first full season - at Double-A Huntsville where he hit .319 with 4 HR, 40 RBI, 28 stolen bases, and a .793 OPS in 106 games. When he opens next season in Triple-A Columbus, he won't turn 22 until mid-May, almost two months into the season. Brantley was in line to be a sure-fire Brewers top ten rated prospect going into next year, and in a much stronger and deeper Indians system is a borderline top ten guy.

...At 21 years of age, Brantley has displayed an elite level approach at the plate striking out just 27 times in 420 at bats this past season, and ranked second in the entire minor leagues with a strikeout per plate appearance ratio of 17.7 (27 K in 479 PA). In his four year minor league career, Brantley has struck out just 142 times in 1633 total plate appearances (11.5 AB/K). While he has only drawn 199 walks in his career, he has an extraordinary ability to consistently put the bat on the ball

His power numbers don't jump off the page, but reports say that he has bulked up to around 200 pounds. Supported by his 6'3 frame, one would deduce that his OPS will rise as he gets older. I remember another prospect the Tribe got from the Expos who didn't have much power in the minors either (Grady Sizemore anyone?). With the luxury of having Sizemore and his 33 homeruns patrolling center, Brantley would not be heavily relied upon for power anyways, just setting the table.

With Brantley being invited to Spring Training with the big club this spring, Wedge and Co. will be keeping a close eye on his development and production in Cactus League action. I imagine they will closely evaluate his defensive progression as well as his eye at the plate. He will be probably be compared and contrasted with fellow Columbus Clipper Trevor Crowe, but if Chris Antonetti is comparing Crowe to Coco Crisp (low OBP guy), I imagine Brantley is currently the more thought of prospect. If Mike can get on base, cover some ground, and rip it up early in Clipperville, the Sabathia trade may have garnered the Indians a much needed leadoff hitter of the Present.

Winter Press tour Sandusky Style

I was able to attend the Indians Winter Caravan on Monday at the Kalahari Convention Center in Sandusky, Ohio where David Huff, Ryan Garko, Derek Shelton, and Matt Underwood answered the fans questions, signed some autographs, and met the fans. Not much of any substance came from the 1 hour session, other than David Huff seems shy, Garko seemed a bit surprised by Wedge's thoughts of him in the outfield, and Derek Shelton speaking the company line. Garko further talked about the possible transition...

Garko expressed surprise that he may be asked to play the outfield.

‘‘One of my friends sent me a text message saying that he read in the paper I was going out there,’’ Garko explained. ‘‘That’s fine with me, though nobody has said anything to me. If Eric Wedge thinks it helps the team, then I’ll do everything I can to help.’’ from the Sandusky Register

The event was quite large and had games, ball park food and beer. I went to one similar to this last year at Stampers bar in Fairview Park that was much more interactive and interesting. The three following videos will give you the gist of the whole event.

Part 1 with David Huff



Part 2 with Ryan Garko

Part 3


Only 3 weeks until Pitchers and Catchers report!

Answering the Fans

I was lucky enough to attend an Indians season ticket holders' Town Hall event held at Westlake High School Tuesday where Assistant GM Chris Antoneti and Manager Eric Wedge, among others (Bob Dibiasio, Dennis Lehman) answered some questions from the common folk. The usual softball questions were asked as I expected, since we all were pretty much just fans excited to talk to the leaders of our favorite club. The panel was extremely cordial and answered even the stupid questions about signing big name free agents. I was able to record about 15 minutes of it, (I am the guy who asked about the teams' philosophy on injuries and if the Tribe would resign Manny) and took a few mental notes as well. This first video is about Travis Hafner and Jake Westbrook.

Here is a synopsis of what I heard

When Wedge was asked about Andy Marte, he basically said they haven't been able to tap into his full potential in Cleveland and that it might have to happen somewhere else. Said for some guys sometimes their ability to stay consistant just clicks on one day(used the example of Casey Blake after 8 years in the minors and Jamie Moyer, saying he remembers facing him in the minors). I would say Marte is pretty much done as an Indian.

Wedge said they wouldn't have guessed Cliff Lee would accomplish the season he had after his first spring training start (joked that he asked Carl Willis what the two had been working on all winter). After his amazing April continued into May and June, Wedge knew Lee's season would be special. Told Cliff after CC was traded, he was the man, his ace. Also mentioned Kelly Shoppach while speaking about Lee prominantly, so don't be surprised to see a Lee/Shoppach battery most of the time.

Antonetti spoke about how the Indians decided to bring in Carl Pavano. Said he was in the best shape he had been in 4 years. Pavano also bluntly talked about that he pretty much sucked in New York and was ready for a big comeback. Apparently the team was impressed with his desire to bounce back and Pavano seemed to be the most physically recovered reclamation project out there. Stressed it was a low risk/high reward signing.

Wedge spoke about how Josh Barfield needs to develop some more "flexibility" in his game to make the club, saying that he may need to learn the outfield to become more versatile. Also talked about Ryan Garko learning some left field (yikes!) for when Victor Martinez plays first. Doesn't have any illusions that Garko will be the next Willie Mays out there, but just being serviceable would add to club overall. Also said DeRosa would play some right field for Choo against tougher lefties and that Jamey Carroll may patrol the outfield as well. The skipper seems to really want to be able to juggle his players around to find the right fit any given day. Stressed it was a 162 game season and needs to be treated as such. (never overact to any situation).

Antoneti mentioned 3 players to watch in AA Akron, Carlos Santana, Beau Mills, and Hector Rondon as well as hyping up the AAA Columbus outfield of Matt LaPorta, Michael Brantley, and Trevor Crowe (compared him to Coco Crisp).

Wedge spoke a bit about the usual question that comes up at these type of events, Cleveland's market size and players coming and going. He said that the 10 game losing streak was more of a product of the players' uncertainty about the CC trade talks and felt the team didn't really give their best effort. Said a lot of players got exposure last year to the big league team that they normally would not have, and will help come 2009. Mentioned that the two biggest team leaders left (Sabathia, Blake) but more talent will come on through (mentioned Matt LaPorta, David Huff). Antonetti talked about even though the season was a disappointment, they were able to replenish the farm system more than expected through their various deals.

When I asked about the teams feeling concerning disclosing injuries, Wedge and Antonetti both basically said that the team would lose a competitive advantage if they told the media every little bump and bruise. (The video is below).

It was a fun experience for my wife Lynsey and I to go out and hear about our beloved Tribe (It was also the first time we left our 1 month old son at Grandma's house). The event gave the fans an up close feeling of where the front office hopes and feels the team will be in 2009. We will be off to the winter caravan tour in Sandusky with Ryan Garko and David Huff Monday so I will have some stuff up here about that as well. Here is the last clip which is really just financial talk and kind of boring. For all you Derek Jeter fans there is some drooling over him in here as well. Enjoy!